Your search results

Short-Term vs Long-Term Rentals on the North Coast — The Updated Guide to Choosing Your Rental Strategy (Updated 16 November 2026)

Posted by James Oosterman on November 17, 2026
0

Updated 16 November 2026

Owners on the North Coast usually rent in one of two ways: short-term to holiday guests, or long-term to tenants on a lease. Each suits a different owner. Here’s how they compare on income, effort, seasons, owner use, rules and tax.

Quick Answers

What is the difference?

Short-term rentals host holiday guests for nights or weeks; long-term rentals house a tenant for months or a year under a written lease.

Mid-term rentals of one to six months sit in between.

Many owners mix approaches through the year.

Which earns more?

Short-term rentals usually earn higher nightly rates and more in total in strong locations, at the cost of more management; long-term rentals earn steadier, lower income with less turnover.

North Coast net yields have been independently corroborated at 6.5% to 8.1%.

Location, configuration and management decide where a property falls.

How do seasons affect each?

Short-term income peaks in the winter dry season, December to April, and in Cabarete’s kite summer, June to August; long-term income is flat through the year.

Long-term renting suits owners who want to avoid seasonal swings.

Short-term suits owners who want peak-season rates.

What about using the property myself?

Short-term renting allows owners to block their own weeks; a long-term lease gives the tenant the property for the term.

Owners who visit often usually choose short-term renting.

Owners who rarely visit often choose long-term.

Which needs more management?

Short-term: guest communication, cleaning, turnover, maintenance and pricing. Long-term: tenant selection, rent collection and maintenance.

Blue Sail Realty’s in-house management team handles both for owners abroad.

The firm’s separate rental department handles rental enquiries.

What rules apply to long-term leases?

Law 85-25, the 2025 rental law: a written lease, a deposit of no more than two months’ rent lodged at Banco Agrícola or Banreservas, registration of the lease, and eviction only by court order.

Six- and twelve-month furnished leases are common.

Tenants usually pay electricity and internet.

What rules apply to short-term renting?

The building’s or community’s rules, which may allow, restrict or centralise short-term renting.

Confirm them in writing before choosing the strategy.

Gated communities set their own guest rules.

How is rental income taxed?

For non-resident owners, 27% is withheld on gross rent; residents declare rental income on the progressive scale.

The same rules apply to both strategies.

A home-country adviser confirms the combined position.

Which property suits which strategy?

Beach-near condos and pool villas suit short-term renting; well-located condos and homes near town and services suit long-term tenants.

Three-bedroom pool villas are the strongest short-term category in the mid band.

Long-term tenants value proximity to schools, shops and work.

How does Blue Sail Realty help owners choose?

By comparing both strategies for your specific property on real comparables, and managing whichever you choose.

Blue Sail Realty has worked the North Coast since 2006.

James Oosterman, Broker/CEO, holds the CIPS designation few Dominican agents hold.

Side by Side

The choice: Short-term for higher rates and owner use; long-term for steady income and less turnover.

Short-term Long-term
IncomeHigher, seasonalSteadier, lower
ManagementIntensiveLighter
Owner useBlock your own weeksTenant has the property
RulesBuilding or community rulesLaw 85-25
SeasonsWinter and kite-summer peaksFlat through the year
Best propertyBeach-near condos, pool villasCondos and homes near services

Methodology

Rental law per Law 85-25 (2025), as summarised by Pellerano & Herrera. Yields per Dominican Today (August 2026). Rental tax per DGII. Seasons per Blue Sail Realty local knowledge. General information, not investment advice; reviewed quarterly.

Questions to choose a strategy:

  • “How often will I use the property?”
  • “Does the building allow short-term renting?”
  • “Do I prefer steady income or peak rates?”
  • “Who will manage guests or tenants?”
  • “What do comparable properties earn each way?”

Sources and further reading:

Law No. 85-25; Dominican Today (August 2026); DGII. General information, not investment advice.

More from Blue Sail Realty: Short-Term Rentals That Perform · Law 85-25 for Landlords · Lifestyle vs Yield · Sample Rental Pro-Forma · Property Management

About the author: James Oosterman, CIPS (Certified International Property Specialist), is Broker/CEO of Blue Sail Realty, headquartered in Cabarete on the Dominican Republic’s North Coast, with nearly 20 years of experience and a 5.0 Google rating. Read real client stories.

Want to see Blue Sail Realty first next time you search? Add us as a preferred source on Google.

Leave a Reply

Compare Listings